Type
Pure rules.
Context
chip is defined for chip_enrolled and adds per_capita_chip, so the chip variable respects eligibility and take-up through enrollment.
healthcare_benefit_value, however, currently adds per_capita_chip directly rather than chip or another enrollment-gated CHIP value. That means household health benefit value can include CHIP value for CHIP-eligible people even when takes_up_chip_if_eligible is false.
Why this matters
As Populace and PE-US distinguish eligibility, take-up, and enrollment more carefully, household-level health resource accounting should not count CHIP benefits for people who do not enroll. This can affect both household net-resource outputs and aggregate health benefit estimates.
Suggested direction
- Change
healthcare_benefit_value to add an enrollment-gated CHIP value, likely chip, unless there is an intentional reason to use gross eligible value.
- If gross CHIP value is needed for a separate accounting concept, expose/document that separately from household benefit value.
- Add tests where a child is CHIP eligible but
takes_up_chip_if_eligible is false.
Acceptance criteria
healthcare_benefit_value does not include CHIP value for non-enrolled people.
- Existing CHIP budget/resource variables have documented gross vs net and eligible vs enrolled semantics.
- Tests cover CHIP eligible+takes-up, CHIP eligible+does-not-take-up, and CHIP ineligible cases.
Type
Pure rules.
Context
chipis defined forchip_enrolledand addsper_capita_chip, so thechipvariable respects eligibility and take-up through enrollment.healthcare_benefit_value, however, currently addsper_capita_chipdirectly rather thanchipor another enrollment-gated CHIP value. That means household health benefit value can include CHIP value for CHIP-eligible people even whentakes_up_chip_if_eligibleis false.Why this matters
As Populace and PE-US distinguish eligibility, take-up, and enrollment more carefully, household-level health resource accounting should not count CHIP benefits for people who do not enroll. This can affect both household net-resource outputs and aggregate health benefit estimates.
Suggested direction
healthcare_benefit_valueto add an enrollment-gated CHIP value, likelychip, unless there is an intentional reason to use gross eligible value.takes_up_chip_if_eligibleis false.Acceptance criteria
healthcare_benefit_valuedoes not include CHIP value for non-enrolled people.